Friday, June 23, 2017

This is brilliant

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/victor-udoewa/does-the-free-market-corrode_b_3844212.html

Does the Free Market Corrode Moral Character?


Yes, it does.
But there are a few problems with my answer. First, what is a free market? Second, what does corrode mean? Lastly, what is moral character?
First, let’s be honest. Theoretically, the free market is amoral. What makes it moral or immoral is the morality of the individual players in the free market. The free market is simply a marketplace or system in which buyers and sellers set their own prices based on competition, supply, and demand without state regulation or restriction. It is possible to experience moral or immoral outcomes in such a free market. However, the unregulated, ideal free market does not exist. Every actual “free” market system, today, exists within some regulatory context from state to state. So, for the purpose of this question, we will look at practical “free markets” which have “little” regulation, or at least relatively less regulation compared to socialism, communism, or considerably controlled forms of capitalism. On to our main question: Does the free market corrode moral character?
Economist Qingliang uses China as an example of a country with an increasingly free market but with instances of declining moral order and business ethics while economist Jagdish Bhagwati cites Vietnam as an example in which “free” markets have led to instances of highly moral outcomes. Whom do we believe?
The question would be relatively easy to answer if all we needed were examples of two countries with free market systems in which country A has high corrosion of moral character and country B has low corrosion. If that were so, the answer would seem to be no: Free markets don’t corrode moral character. The major problem is that even if the free market does corrode moral character, there can be counteracting factors. What if the free market corrodes moral character and country B simply has an amazing, mandatory child, youth, and adult national service program that builds up moral character? The only way to truly test the question would be to run a tightly controlled statistical experiment in multiple societies in which you control for everything, only allowing the market system to differ (which naturally changes other things in society). How do you do that? Without such an experiment, it’s hard to say if other confounding factors are also affecting the moral character of country B or if another factor is affecting both the market system and moral character.
Instead of trying to prove causation which is very difficult, let’s focus on the practical, correlational question: Does moral character tend to erode in societies with free markets? Again, I say yes, but it depends on our next sub-questions: What does corrode mean, and what is moral character?
Much of the debate over the main question is settled when you define the time scale. If “corrode” means the erosion of moral character over a few years or in the first generation of a free market system, you might answer the main question with a resounding no: Free markets don’t corrode moral character. Look at the move from European feudalism or Japanese isolationism to their “free” market systems of today, you might suggest. And it’s true that in the first generation(s) of a free market system you do see individuals displaying good moral character through risk-taking, industriousness, forward-thinking, and perseverance. However, when someone pulls herself up by her bootstraps, makes a living for herself, and betters her life, those qualities do not always pass down to her children or progeny who are now born into families with much more disposable income, reserve capital, and wealth. The descendants do not necessarily have to work hard, take risks, or be innovative. Sociologist Daniel Bell noted the cultural contradiction of capitalism due to the cyclical decay in moral character after generations of wealth accumulation because incentives change through the generations. Some are rebellious, some resent the family wealth, others take wealth for granted, etc. When someone says that moral character has been built up in a particular society experimenting with a free market system, I ask, “Have you observed it long enough?” I’m interested in long-term effects on the society.
Still, no matter the time scale, the answer to the overall question depends on the final point: what is moral character? It all depends on your moral system as Ayaan Ali and Professor John Gray point out. On one hand, if freedom is the highest aim in your moral system, then a free-market system might be morally improving upon human character. Markets can improve certain morals. Markets are a means of social integration. People come together and interact, learning collaborative skills. It’s possible to learn empathy, form bonds, create trust, and experience solidarity. To be part of a market as a producer, you must work hard, take risks, be innovative, set visions, think ahead, stake out the playing field. It can develop within you a strong work ethic and increase your industriousness.
At the same time, other negative traits can be pronounced in a free market system. The gains and risks in the free market can be so high that people distrust one another, betray allies, and conceal plans. Pressure to succeed kicks in and we have extreme public examples of moral failures like Enron, the Great Recession, and the Madoff scandal. There are huge incentives and tremendous pressure to break the rules of moral conduct and then justify the breaking of that conduct just to reach the bottom line as Professor Michael Walzer explains.
However, even if it does corrode moral character, Philosopher Bernard-Henri Levy says the free market is the best system we have: If the free market corrodes human character, other systems corrode it absolutely or to a greater extent. I don’t like this statement as an answer because the question is not relative. We are not trying to find out if the free market is the least bad of all options, we are only asking if it corrodes human character. If it does, we should improve upon it, look for a better alternative, or create a better system.
Still Henri-Levy’s answer does excite me because it gets to the heart of my answer. Free market apologists tend to criticize systems like communism on the basis of its communal corrosion of character. Implicitly they understand that there is such a thing as communal moral character. Critics like Levy and Garry Kasparov point to the experience of loss of aspiration and degradation of character due to the loss of freedom in authoritarian economic regimes: The USSR experienced communal terror and an entire culture in East Germany lost the ability to make decisions. Far from critiquing any individual loss, Levy and Kasparov are making statements about communal effects that trickle down to most citizens in the country. Criticisms of individual moral failures in authoritarian regimes are usually applied to corrupt officials or authoritarian leaders. The bulk of the critique is on the communal effects.
However, when we talk of the moral failures of free market systems, it is usually applied to individuals. Kay Hymowitz provides an example of a critique on communal character by noting the communal decline of the family and marriage in our post-marital society. Still usually, the critique is about individuals, individual freedoms, and individual mistakes. The communal critique is lost.
It’s not just that a single person, like Bernie Madoff, has an incentive to conceal, deceive, and steal to make his bottom line, but that in the same way, we do not call it communal stealing when money can be shifted from the poorer classes to the rich as in predatory lending (and now predatory microfinance in which organizations can charge 100 percent interest rates). As Michael Walzer explains, we regulate theft and extortion on individual levels but there are forms of market behavior which fall under extortion or theft (such as the ability of big business to unfairly influence the price of the goods they sell) which are not regulated or not regulated well enough. Entire pockets of society can lack access to markets or submarkets (like the health market) based on socioeconomic levels: They cannot even participate. These examples display a type of degradation of communal human character that I see, a type we do not name as readily as individual character mistakes and flaws, due to a love of individualism — the supremacy of individual freedom. What I look for, find beauty in, and prefer is individuality without individualism, a type of unity-in-community, being-in-interbeing, to use a Brian McLaren phrase. Without individualism, we are more than individuals, we are interdividuals (RenĂ© Girard<). It’s this aspect which seems to be missing from our understanding of the effects of the free market. For me the identity of an individual is only defined within community, not in isolation. So communal character effects are prioritized for me; they influence individual moral action. And it is this tendency toward the corrosion of communal character in today’s actual free markets, that makes me answer the question yes.
Still, I do not necessarily advocate a different political economy. I actually do not know what system would be better, though I am willing to work with others to create one. Perhaps, a possible solution is more subtle than a change of systems. One of the communal moral corrosions that I see all around will help explain this — a lack of satisfaction.
I never have enough. Larger incomes demand larger expenses. I am always looking to the next promotion, the next salary increase, a better job, a bigger house — something else or something more that I don’t have that will satisfy me. We try to (temporarily) satisfy these cravings through various offerings: money, fame, power, sex, food, etc. But we still want more. Peter Rollins points out that some faith groups substitute God as another offering in the vending machine of (dis)satisfaction. However, the truly radical Christian move is to see God (as experienced through Christ) as destroying the entire vending machine of (dis)satisfaction. Instead of offering another (dis)satisfying option, in radical Christian theology, Christ can be seen as one who embraces fragility, brokenness, dissatisfaction, and vulnerability and invites us to do the same. Yet, there is a kernel of hope. It is in this embracing of brokenness and dissatisfaction that you find freedom, as you come alongside others who are suffering, simply be present, share yourself, and suffer with them; there is love. And where there is love, there is an experience of what Professor John Caputo calls the event of God.
Inside macroeconomic free market systems, I have met pockets of communities, today, that practice countercultural redistribution. Like a 1st century community recorded in Acts, there share everything they have and there is no one needy among them. Compare that with extreme economic examples: capitalism (great at production, poor at distribution) and communism (great at distribution, poor at production). What is striking is that ideal communism forces people to share when they don’t necessarily want to do so. Ideal capitalism gives people the freedom to share when they do not necessarily want to do so. These countercultural micro-communities stand at a strange contrast between the two ideal extremes because they show a people who are free to share and actually choose to share. They have not enacted a change in economic systems, they simply have a transformation of heart. So it is in these spaces between the margins in which I find hope. They possibly foreshadow a time, as Shane Claiborne says, when free market capitalism is obsolete and communism is unnecessary.

Wednesday, June 21, 2017

Why your ideology (and mine too) is a granfalloon

I often suffer existential crises, particularly regarding my belief system. I have, for most of my life, been pretty willing to ask questions of myself and others; to doubt and examine assumptions; to be a skeptic; to cherish the truth. It's probably why I was eventually attracted to getting a degree in philosophy, despite the perception that it's not useful.

The concept that hooked me was Kierkegaard's: passion in uncertainty. We are passionate about the things of which we are uncertain, the things we fear (to either come to pass or not come to pass). We are not passionate about the answer to a simple math problem or whether a bird outside ate breakfast this morning. The uncertain things we believe are often ludicrous, which can lead us into having to defend ludicrous things that may not have an easy resolution (or in some cases any proof whatsoever).

The solution lies in understanding the problem. We don't really live in a world where truth is cherished (or even matters). It's hard work and extremely uncomfortable to challenge your own beliefs (much less those of others). A few posts ago, I linked a great comic by The Oatmeal about belief, which I urge you to go read. And now, take the Kierkegaard's concept above, and it seems pretty easy to explain what is happening in our world.

Vonnegut's granfalloons are another way to explain human nature. If you aren't familiar, it is essentially what it is called when a group of people identify with each other based off of inconsequential and irrelevant details. For instance, liking the same book or TV show, being a fan of the same musician or sports team, and most dangerously to free thought, subscribing to a political or religious ideology. Or nationalism. I am not saying that politics and religion are inherently bad. But the phenomenon that occurs, is that once the granfalloon is formed and its members are identified, it starts to look at others outside the granfalloon as "Other" and "enemy". It over-simplifies the defining characteristics of the Other in the same way it has over-simplified the defining characteristics of its own granfalloon. And then the arguing starts. Followed by words and acts of hatred. All based off of inconsequential details and connections that aren't really connections.

So, back to my latest crisis of faith. Like many others in the country right now, I am gravely concerned about what is going on in the world, in our country, in our discourse, and just basically in the way in which we treat each other. Whatever is going on politically is not working. And yet each side argues that it's the other's fault (because there are only two sides in the U.S.; by the way, a fallacy of false alternatives occurs whenever only two options present themselves, when in reality, there are many more available). Each side holds the entire populace hostage in its adherence to its identified ideology. This is not a new problem, meaning it is not solely the fault of the current administration. I'd argue that we have the current administration as a direct result of the existence of this problem, which ironically, has amplified the problem to near unbearable levels.

The ideology holds certain values and certain things to be true, and they come as a package deal. If you claim to be a part of that granfalloon, then you have to hold all of those values and beliefs. After that, critical thought and empathy go out the window. All you have to do is go down the check boxes to see where you are supposed to fall on an issue. Problem is, as over-complicated as we like to make life, this approach is too simple. There's no nuance. The ideology supersedes the individuals of which it is comprised. The individual is no longer represented. It's why lifelong Democrats are pissed and disappointed in their own party, and why Republicans have split into different factions over the past decade or so.

If you're starting to think the solution is sounding like a path to becoming a Libertarian, I explored that too. Problem is, for every Libertarian you meet, you will either find another set of dogmas, or you will find drastically different shades of Libertarian. All will claim to be the only right way. There's a lot to admire in the ideology of the Libertarian, but at best it is an unrealistic thought experiment; an ideal that ironically only works if everyone were Libertarian (which is antithesis to its core tenet of individual freedom). It elevates the individual so much that it is hard to square with any kind of compassionate belief system. It ignores the social contract, and by extension social determinants that foster inequality. It ignores that the free market is a nice idea, but that in reality, will not exist because of inequality; because those already with power and money will almost always do whatever it takes to keep it--and since we live in a world with limited resources, that means others will continue to go without. We can't realistically end all suffering, but I fail to see how the Libertarian ideology won't simply devolve into Might Makes Right. Either that, or Libertarians are really optimistic about human nature.

We have to treat each other better. We have to develop empathy. We need to enter into meaningful discourse. We need to learn from each other, and listen. Hearts and minds are not changed (in a positive way) by violence. That just leads to fear and more violence. And fear is a tool to keep people from actual liberty.

It might sound stupid, but I always think about the Federation from Star Trek. In this fictional thought experiment, not only have different nations overcome their different ideologies, but different planets, races, species have aligned for the betterment of all. So whenever I see Nationalism rising back up in the U.S. rhetoric, in European countries wanting to leave the EU; when I see borders becoming more important than globalism, those things are a step backwards from the potential future we are shown in Star Trek.

You can't stop progress. Technology. An international global economy. Outdated manufacturing and other diminishing blue collar jobs are not coming back. Desperately trying to hold onto to ideologies of the past, be they religious, anti-science and technology, socioeconomic, or simply not being able to get over that different kinds of people are actually people is only going to prolong everyone's suffering.

Tuesday, May 30, 2017

Hope in darkness

" People are people, and we are the way we are. We’re all supposed to get along, and diversity should be appreciated fully in the light of unity. That’s peace on earth, and there should be room for everyone."--David Lynch

Friday, May 27, 2016

River Lethe's Best Music of 2016


Aesop Rock - The Impossible Kid

Image result for allegaeon proponent for sentience
Allegaeon - Proponents for Sentience


Image result for anciients voice of the void

Anciients - Voice of the Void


Image result for black peaks statues
Black Peaks - Statues



Bloc Party - Hymns

Image result for bossk audio noir
Bossk - Audio Noir


Image result for car bomb meta
Car Bomb - Meta

Image result for child bite negative noise

Child Bite - Negative Noise

Image result for cobalt slow forever

Cobalt - Slow Forever




David Bowie - Blackstar

Image result for deathspell omega the synarchy of molten bones

Deathspell Omega - The Synarchy of Molten Bones


Image result for every time i die low teens
Every Time I Die - Low Teens


Image result for if these trees could talk the bones of a dying world
If These Trees Could Talk - The Bones of a Dying World

Image result for ihsahn arktis

Ihsahn - Arktis


Image result for krizz kaliko go
Krizz Kaliko - Go

Image result for los disidentes del sucio motel human collapse

Los Disidentes del Sucio Motel - Human Collapse


Image result for neurosis fires within fires

Neurosis - Fires Within Fires


Image result for nick cave and the bad seeds skeleton tree

Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds - Skeleton Tree



O'Brother - Endless Light


Image result for obsidian kingdom a year without summer
Obsidian Kingdom - A Year With No Summer

Image result for red fang only ghosts

Red Fang - Only Ghosts


Image result for russian circles guidance
Russian Circles - Only Ghosts



Sam Beam & Jesca Hoop - Love Letter For Fire


Image result for schammasch triangle
Schammasch - Triangle


Zhrine - Unortheta

Tuesday, May 24, 2016

Thursday, April 21, 2016

Remembering the "Satanic Panic"



I'm sure I'm not alone in this, but somehow throughout my childhood and adolescence, I was interested in several of the things that became cultural taboos for a time. I understand that it is human nature to fear, and specifically, to fear for your child. My parents fell for the fundamentalist, ignorant garbage that was the "satanic panic" of the 80's. As a result, we constantly battled over my interests. My interest in D&D and other RPGs was "unhealthy". Not once did anyone ever ask me (not that I would have been eloquent enough to explain it; I was a kid after all) why these things were important to me. I was a little nerd. I was an introvert; shy and uncomfortable around most people. I wasn't really into sports after grade school. I was constantly made fun of and bullied through middle school.  This was my way to cope with a world that I did not feel welcome in. I found a small group of people with whom I could share this game, and they were like me in many ways. Ultimately, my parents would actually, literally make me burn all of my RPG books in the backyard one day. I did not stop playing, and would periodically revisit it (and things like it) throughout my adult life. In fact, I didn't really stop until after 4th Edition came out.

Likewise, as I got a bit older, my musical tastes changed as well. My parents also became concerned about this.  They actually thought I might be gay at one point (which of course was also horrific to them) because I liked Michael Jackson, Duran Duran and Prince (RIP!). I quickly moved through different genres, eventually getting to rock and hip hop, and then to metal. They repeated patterns of fear and misunderstanding, being led by such influential figures as James Dobson and Focus on the Family. Their involvement in our church (ironically) became obsessive.  We were there ALL THE TIME. First to arrive, last to leave. I had to go to every youth event they offered. And I was the black sheep there as well. There were many long discussions turned to arguments over my musical taste, eventually ending in the same result as before. Albums confiscated from me because they were deemed unhealthy. My musical tastes are as varied (and extreme in some cases) as ever.  See my blog here for evidence.

I still see these types of fears taking over today.  Blame mental illness for mass shootings, never mind that we as a country do not really understand mental illness and its stigma. Never mind that statistically, violent crime is not associated with mental illness.  Blame drugs or addiction.  Blame the poor. Blame other religions. Blame the government.  It's all a series of granfaloons, of making distinctions between the Self and the Other.  Look, terrible things happen.  Sometimes people are simply awful (and it's not because of videogames or whatever other modern taboo you want to assign to it). And we shouldn't be surprised by this; there are more people on the planet than there ever has been before. If a certain percentage are bad, then it follows that more people means more bad people. But it also means more good people.  Or even take morality out of it altogether. It's more people in general, who have the same needs, wants, hopes, desires and dreams as you.

I'm still into fantasy and science fiction. I still love metal. I love horror movies. My RPG interest has been replaced with a love of other types of tabletop games.  I love to create, whether it's through food or music or writing or whatever strikes my fancy.

The main thing that has changed? Now I'm a parent.  And I hope to never forget what it was like growing up being (and discovering) me.  I hope to pass these things on to my son, and I plan to encourage creativity, imagination and free thinking.  If he gets interested in something I don't understand or don't care for, I hope that instead of scapegoating I will make an effort to understand what it is he enjoys about it first. Correlation is not causation (and sometimes it's not even really correlation in the first place). I hope to be able to share things that are meaningful (and fun) together, but must also be prepared to let go (and when) our interests diverge. And I will find a way to talk about things in a way that doesn't further alienate us from one another. Maybe that was my parents' intent as well, and it just got away from them (I blame religion and fear-mongering). But I strongly believe that you cannot move towards understanding with someone if your first assertion to them is that what they are doing or who they are is wrong.

Aesop Rock - Rings